Order Online
Best Greek Salad in Winnipeg at Johnny's Maples

Best Greek Salad in Winnipeg

(156 reviews)

When Nancy Squire declared in her November 2024 review that we have the "Best Greek Salad in Winnipeg," she was echoing what customers have been saying for nearly five decades. Our Greek Salad isn't just another menu item - it's a direct taste of the Mediterranean, prepared according to the traditional recipe Johnny Vagianos learned in his homeland of Kalymnos, Greece. Fresh, crisp romaine lettuce forms the foundation for vine-ripened tomatoes, cool cucumbers, tangy red onions, crisp green peppers, authentic Kalamata olives, and generous chunks of creamy feta cheese, all brought together with our house-made Greek vinaigrette featuring extra virgin olive oil and aromatic herbs.

Fresh Daily
Authentic Greek
Highly Rated

A Taste of the Greek Islands in Every Bite

In Greece, a proper salad isn't an afterthought or a side dish - it's a celebration of fresh ingredients at their peak. When Johnny Vagianos opened his restaurant in 1977, he brought this philosophy with him from the island of Kalymnos. Our Greek Salad follows the traditional Mediterranean approach: simple, fresh ingredients that speak for themselves, enhanced (never masked) by a light dressing.

What sets our Greek Salad apart is our unwavering commitment to quality and authenticity. We receive fresh produce deliveries daily. The feta cheese is authentic Greek-style - not the crumbly domestic version, but creamy, tangy blocks that we cut fresh. The Kalamata olives are imported, not substituted with cheaper alternatives. Our house-made vinaigrette uses real extra virgin olive oil, red wine vinegar, fresh garlic, oregano, and a touch of lemon juice - the way it's been made in Greek kitchens for generations.

The Ingredients Make the Difference

Crisp Romaine Lettuce

Fresh, crunchy, and delivered daily - the perfect base

Vine-Ripened Tomatoes

Sweet, juicy tomatoes bursting with natural flavor

Cool Cucumbers

Fresh and crisp, adding refreshing texture to every bite

Authentic Feta Cheese

Creamy, tangy Greek-style feta cut fresh from the block

Kalamata Olives

Imported Greek olives with that distinctive rich, fruity flavor

House-Made Dressing

Traditional Greek vinaigrette with extra virgin olive oil and herbs

More Than a Side - A Meal in Itself

While our Greek Salad makes an excellent accompaniment to any entrée, many customers order it as their main dish - and for good reason. The generous portions and nutritious combination of fresh vegetables, protein-rich feta, and healthy fats from olive oil create a satisfying, complete meal. It's the perfect choice when you want something light yet filling, healthy yet indulgent, simple yet incredibly flavorful.

A Customer Favorite for Nearly 50 Years

Our Greek Salad has earned countless 5-star reviews and has become one of our most-ordered items. Customers who've traveled to Greece tell us ours tastes "just like the real thing." Those with Greek heritage say it reminds them of their yiayia's cooking. And newcomers to Greek cuisine discover why this simple combination has been beloved in the Mediterranean for centuries.

Winnipeg's Verdict: Best Greek Salad

Nancy Squire

Google Reviewer

"Best Greek Salad in Winnipeg."

November 2024

Aircanman4

TripAdvisor Reviewer

"Went with friends today for a late lunch. Ordered the Lunch Special with Caesar Salad - all very good and the service was excellent. The Greek Salad here is legendary!"

March 2020

Elena K.

Regular Customer

"As someone of Greek descent, I'm very picky about Greek salads. This is the real deal - authentic feta, proper olives, and that dressing is perfection. My family orders this every single time we visit Johnny's."

December 2025

Craving the Best Greek Salad in Winnipeg?

Order online for pickup or delivery - fresh Mediterranean flavors delivered to your door

Order Now View Full Menu

Visit Johnny's Maples Pizza & Restaurant

Contact Information

670 Sheppard St, Winnipeg, MB R2X 1R2

+1 204-633-2718

Hours:

  • Monday-Friday: 8:00 AM - 8:00 PM
  • Saturday: 8:00 AM - 9:00 PM
  • Sunday: 11:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Get Directions